I've been toying with the idea of starting this blog for a while now, and when I saw the front page of todays Arizona Daily Star it seemed the perfect entry point.
The AZ Daily Star reported today on the front page that Tucson has made Forbes list of the Top 10 most overvalued cities. "Tucson is keeping big-name company with New York City, Los Angeles and San Francisco in an unfortunate Top-10 list: It puts us among the country's most overpriced places."
Hard to believe that Tucson would make this list, even given the big run-up in home prices during the last few years. It wasn't long ago that Tucson caught the attention of the media because many surveys
(The next hot housing markets) - (are you living in a bubble) rated Tucson a relative bargain in terms of home prices compared to other hot markets.Forbes notes that the median home price in Tucson is currently $248,600. That is incorrect. According to the Tucson Association of Realtors MLS the median home price in Tucson is currently $221,250. (see MLS sales data above) Forbes figure is off by 12.36%.
Forbes' top 10 overvalued cities
● The 10 most overpriced places in the United States and their median home prices, according to a Forbes.com ranking that considered cost of living, job growth, housing affordability and salaries.
1. Essex County, Mass.: $373,750
2. San Francisco: $720,400
3. San Jose, Calif.: $746,800
4. Honolulu: $625,000
5. Cambridge, Mass.: $390,400
6. New York: $528,700
7. Tucson: $248,600
8. Oakland, Calif.: $720,400
9. Boston: $390,400
10. Los Angeles: $563,900
$221,250 is low compared to the other cities on the Top 10 list & probably compared to a lot of cities not on the list. (By the way, The National median existing single-family home price was $229,700 in May, up 6.4 percent from a year ago)
But for the moment, the inaccuracy aside, when Forbes says overvalued, they are saying overvalued in relation to cost of living, job growth & salaries. That works in most places. But in Tucson there is another component, and it's a big one, that drives the local economy and the cost of housing. And that is, that a large part of Tucsons' economy is fueled by tourism, retirees and seasonal visitors, people who come here to get away from where they live or used to live, and not for jobs, but for pleasure. Just like Honolulu, # 4 on Forbes list.
And, like it or not, a lot of the value in Tucson home prices is driven by demand for second homes and retirement homes. These people come here because they want to, because Tucson is beautiful, has a great climate and an easy lifestyle. And none of it has to do with jobs & salaries. So when Forbes says that Tucson is overvalued they have not taken into account a big chunk of what our economy is about. Does anyone buy a second home or retirement home in Gary, Indiana or Hoboken, New Jersey?
Recent Comments